Checklist for Reviewing Agreements

Ensuring Legal and Commercial Soundness

Checklist for Reviewing Agreements

Ensuring Legal and Commercial Soundness

Introduction

Contracts and agreements form the backbone of commercial relationships and legal obligations in the modern world. A thorough review ensures enforceability, fairness, and risk mitigation, whether for business partnerships, supply agreements, employment contracts, or non-disclosure agreements. This note provides a detailed checklist to evaluate agreements’ legal and commercial soundness.

Contracts serve as a roadmap for the rights, obligations, and expectations of the parties involved. A poorly drafted or inadequately reviewed contract can lead to misunderstandings, disputes, and financial losses. Conversely, a carefully reviewed agreement helps establish clarity, manage risks, and build trust.

This checklist aims to serve as a comprehensive guide for legal professionals, business owners, and other stakeholders. By systematically addressing each aspect of an agreement, from preliminary considerations to post-execution obligations, one can ensure its alignment with legal requirements and business objectives.

Reviewing agreements is a critical skill for legal and commercial professionals to ensure compliance, mitigate risks, and uphold the interests of the parties involved. Agreements outline the parties’ rights, obligations, and expectations and are foundational to maintaining a sound commercial relationship. A thorough review ensures not only legal validity but also commercial fairness.

This research note explores the essential elements of reviewing agreements and provides a systematic checklist to assess their legal and commercial soundness.

1. Preliminary Review

The preliminary review phase is critical in setting the foundation for analyzing the agreement. It involves understanding the context and purpose of the document while ensuring that fundamental details are accurate.

1.1 Identification of Parties

Confirm the legal names, addresses, and roles of all parties involved.
Verify the capacity of each party to enter into the agreement (e.g., legal age for individuals, proper authorization for companies).
Ensure that the contract reflects the intended relationship, such as partnership, supplier-buyer, or employer-employee.

1.2 Purpose and Type of Agreement

Identify the type of agreement, such as a service contract, non-disclosure agreement (NDA), lease, or employment contract.
Assess whether the agreement achieves the intended business or personal objective.

1.3 Effective Date and Duration

Check for the effective date, which is often different from the signing date.
Verify the term of the agreement, whether it is fixed, renewable, or indefinite.
Review clauses for termination, renewal, and renegotiation to ensure they are clear and fair.

2. Commercial Terms

The commercial terms form the core of most agreements, detailing the business arrangement and financial aspects. These terms must be clear, specific, and balanced to protect the interests of all parties.
2.1 Scope of Work (SOW)
- Clearly define the responsibilities of each party, including deliverables and performance standards.
- Include any exclusions to avoid misunderstandings about the obligations.
- Specify milestones, deadlines, and reporting requirements.
2.2 Payment Terms
- Confirm the agreed payment structure, such as lump sum, instalments, or milestone-based payments.
- Verify the currency, payment method, and bank details to ensure accuracy.
- Include provisions for penalties in case of delayed payments or non-performance.
2.3 Pricing and Costs
- Ensure that the pricing mechanism (fixed, variable, or cost-plus) is clearly outlined.
- Define how additional costs, such as taxes, duties, or service fees, will be handled.
2.4 Deadlines and Deliverables
- Specify deadlines for the completion of key tasks or delivery of goods/services.
- Incorporate mechanisms for addressing delays, such as liquidated damages or penalty clauses.

3. Legal Soundness

Ensuring legal compliance and enforceability is a fundamental aspect of contract review. This includes analyzing clauses for conformity with applicable laws and regulations.
3.1 Compliance with Applicable Laws
- Verify compliance with local, national, and international laws relevant to the agreement.
- Address industry-specific regulations, such as environmental, labor, or data protection laws.
- Ensure that the contract does not include illegal or unenforceable provisions.
3.2 Intellectual Property (IP) Rights
- Specify ownership and usage rights for intellectual property created or utilized under the agreement.
- Include provisions for licensing, assignment, or joint ownership if applicable.
- Add indemnity clauses to protect against third-party IP infringement claims.
3.3 Confidentiality Clauses
- Clearly define what constitutes confidential information.
- Specify the duration of confidentiality obligations, ensuring they are reasonable and enforceable.
- Provide exceptions for information that is already public or required to be disclosed by law.
3.4 Governing Law and Jurisdiction
- Choose the governing law that will apply to the agreement, particularly for cross-border contracts.
- Include clauses for dispute resolution, such as mediation, arbitration, or litigation.
- Specify the venue and procedural rules for resolving disputes.

4. Risk Management

Contracts often involve inherent risks that must be mitigated through well-drafted clauses. Risk management ensures that liabilities are limited, responsibilities are clear, and remedies are available.
4.1 Termination Clauses
- Define grounds for termination, including breach of contract, insolvency, or force majeure.
- Include notice periods and specify the form of notice (e.g., written, electronic).
- Address post-termination obligations, such as payment of outstanding dues or return of property.
4.2 Warranties and Representations
- Review warranties for accuracy and fairness, ensuring they align with the capabilities of the parties.
- Include remedies for breach of warranties, such as repair, replacement, or compensation.
4.3 Indemnity Provisions
- Clearly outline indemnification obligations, including scope and limitations.
- Address coverage for legal fees, third-party claims, and damages resulting from breaches.
4.4 Limitation of Liability
- Include caps on liability to limit financial exposure.
- Exclude liability for consequential or indirect damages where possible.
4.5 Force Majeure
- Define events considered beyond the parties’ control (e.g., natural disasters, strikes).
- Specify how obligations are modified or suspended during such events.
Include provisions for termination if force majeure persists beyond a reasonable period.

5. Practical Considerations

Beyond the substantive clauses, agreements must be reviewed for clarity, consistency, and practicality to ensure their effectiveness.

5.1 Consistency and Clarity

Ensure consistent use of defined terms throughout the document.
Check for proper formatting, numbering, and cross-references.
Avoid ambiguous language that could lead to misinterpretation.

5.2 Standard Clauses

Include severability clauses to ensure that invalid provisions do not affect the rest of the agreement.
Provide for amendments and waivers to require mutual consent for changes.
Incorporate an “entire agreement” clause to prevent reliance on prior negotiations.

5.3 Execution Formalities

Verify the authority of signatories to bind their respective parties.
Ensure compliance with jurisdictional requirements for execution, such as notarization or stamp duty.

Include provisions for counterparts and electronic signatures if applicable.

6. Post-Execution Obligations

A contract does not end with signing. Proper management of post-execution obligations ensures compliance and avoids disputes.

6.1 Monitoring Performance

Assign responsibility for tracking milestones, deliverables, and timelines.
Implement periodic reviews to ensure compliance with key obligations.

6.2 Renewal and Termination Management

Track deadlines for renewal or termination notices.
Plan for renegotiation of terms well before the contract expires.

6.3 Record Keeping

Maintain a secure repository for executed agreements and related correspondence.
Use contract management software to automate tracking and notifications.

7. Special Considerations for Specific Agreements

Different types of agreements may require tailored approaches during review.

7.1 Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs)

Define confidential information comprehensively.
Limit the duration of confidentiality obligations to a reasonable period.
Include remedies for unauthorized disclosures.

7.2 Employment Contracts

Clearly outline terms of employment, including duties, compensation, and benefits.
Review termination clauses for compliance with labour laws.
Address restrictive covenants, such as non-compete and non-solicitation clauses.

7.3 Service-Level Agreements (SLAs)

Specify performance metrics, such as uptime, response time, or resolution time.
Include penalties for failing to meet agreed service levels.
Define escalation procedures for unresolved issues.

Conclusion

The review of agreements is a vital process to safeguard legal compliance and commercial interests. By adhering to a structured checklist, one can ensure that agreements are comprehensive, enforceable, and aligned with the goals of all parties involved. This proactive approach minimizes risks, prevents disputes, and fosters smoother business relationships.

A well-drafted and thoroughly reviewed agreement ensures legal validity and commercial success. By adhering to a comprehensive checklist, parties can identify and mitigate potential risks, ensure compliance with relevant laws, and foster a fair and transparent business relationship. Contractual diligence not only protects against disputes but also reinforces trust and cooperation between parties.

Contractual diligence is essential to safeguard legal compliance, protect commercial interests, and build trust between parties. By following a structured checklist, one can ensure that agreements are clear, enforceable, and aligned with the objectives of all stakeholders. Regular updates to the review process, based on evolving laws and business needs, are equally important for maintaining effective contractual relationships.

LEGALLANDS assist in services related to Contract Conveyancing, Reviewing Contracts, Vetting Agreements, and Corporate Services, Joint Ventures, Merger Acquisitions, Business Set Up and Management Services, Foreign Trade Policies, Immigration Services, Regulatory Compliances, Legal Compliances, Logistics Support, International Dispute Resolution, Trade Regulations, and many more. We also assist in Due Diligence, Risk Assessment etc. Feel free to connect with us at connect@legallands.com. For further information visit our website on www.legallands.com.

Checklist for Reviewing Agreement

Scope: Understand the scope of the contract and all expectations
Schedule: Is the schedule reasonable and flexible enough to accommodate changes?
Critical clauses: Are the paths that trigger critical clauses clearly communicated?
Risk allocation: Are risks clearly stated and allocated to the parties most capable of managing them?
Dates: Are all dates correct?
Renewal: Do you have a reminder set for renegotiation before renewal?
Key terms: Examine key terms and clauses and insert missing terms
Confidentiality: Verify confidentiality provisions
Language: Strive for clear language
Default terms: Review default terms
Blank fields: Check for blank fields in the agreement
Milestones: Note significant milestones
Remedies: Understand the remedies provisions

Contact

Get the Legal Support You Deserve Schedule Your Free Consultation Now!

Take the first step toward expert legal support. Schedule your free consultation today and get the guidance you need to resolve your legal matters with confidence.

Checklist for Reviewing Agreements